Umbraco-CMS/thoughts/shared/handoffs/general/2025-12-20_18-58-13_contentservice-phase0-subagent-driven-task7.md

date, researcher, git_commit, branch, repository, topic, tags, status, last_updated, last_updated_by, type

date	researcher	git_commit	branch	repository	topic	tags	status	last_updated	last_updated_by	type
2025-12-20T18:58:13+00:00	Claude	3239a4534e	refactor/ContentService	Umbraco-CMS	ContentService Refactoring Phase 0 Implementation	implementation testing benchmarks contentservice refactoring	in_progress	2025-12-20	Claude	implementation_strategy

Handoff: ContentService Refactoring Phase 0 - Test Infrastructure (Task 7+)

Task(s)

Executing Phase 0 of ContentService refactoring using Subagent-Driven Development workflow. Phase 0 creates test and benchmark infrastructure to establish baseline metrics before refactoring begins.

Implementation Plan: docs/plans/2025-12-20-contentservice-refactor-phase0-implementation.md

Task Status (12 total tasks):

Task	Description	Status
Task 0	Commit ContentServiceBenchmarkBase.cs	✅ Completed
Task 1	Create ContentServiceRefactoringTests.cs skeleton	✅ Completed
Task 2	Add notification ordering tests (Tests 1-2)	✅ Completed
Task 3	Add sort operation tests (Tests 3-5)	✅ Completed
Task 4	Add DeleteOfType tests (Tests 6-8)	✅ Completed (this session)
Task 5	Add permission tests (Tests 9-12)	✅ Completed (this session)
Task 6	Add transaction boundary tests (Tests 13-15)	✅ Completed (this session)
Task 7	Create ContentServiceRefactoringBenchmarks.cs	🔲 IN PROGRESS (next task)
Task 8	Create ContentServiceBaseTests.cs	🔲 Pending
Task 9	Run all tests and verify	🔲 Pending
Task 10	Capture baseline benchmarks	🔲 Pending
Task 11	Final verification and summary	🔲 Pending

Critical References

1. Implementation Plan: docs/plans/2025-12-20-contentservice-refactor-phase0-implementation.md - Contains exact code for all tasks. Task 7 is lines 1231-2386.
2. Subagent-Driven Development Skill: ~/.claude/plugins/cache/superpowers-marketplace/superpowers/4.0.0/skills/subagent-driven-development/ - Workflow being followed

Recent changes

• tests/Umbraco.Tests.Integration/Umbraco.Infrastructure/Services/ContentServiceRefactoringTests.cs - Added 12 tests total (15 now in file):
  • Tasks 4-6 added: DeleteOfType tests (3), Permission tests (4), Transaction boundary tests (3)
• Commits made this session:
  • cf74f7850e - Task 4: DeleteOfType tests
  • 7e989c0f8c - Task 5: Permission tests
  • 3239a4534e - Task 6: Transaction boundary tests

Learnings

1. Subagent-Driven Development Workflow:

   • Dispatch implementer subagent with FULL task text from plan (don't make subagent read files)
   • Dispatch spec compliance reviewer to verify implementation matches spec exactly
   • If issues found, dispatch fix subagent, then re-review
   • Dispatch code quality reviewer only AFTER spec compliance passes
   • Mark task complete only when both reviews approve

2. Test Patterns in Umbraco:

   • Base class UmbracoIntegrationTestWithContent provides Textpage, Subpage, Subpage2, Subpage3
   • Textpage is NOT published by default - tests may need to publish parent before creating child content
   • Use ContentBuilder.CreateSimpleContent() to create fresh test content
   • Use RefactoringTestNotificationHandler.Reset() before testing notifications

3. API Deviations from Plan (discovered in Task 5):

   • IUserGroupService is async-only - tests must use async Task pattern
   • Use Constants.Security.EditorGroupKey (Guid) not EditorGroupAlias
   • EntityPermission constructor requires ISet<string> (HashSet), not array

4. Spec Compliance:

   • First implementation of Task 2 deviated from spec (used fixtures instead of creating content)
   • Reviewer caught this and fix was applied successfully
   • Lesson: Spec reviewer is critical for catching deviations

Artifacts

• tests/Umbraco.Tests.Integration/Testing/ContentServiceBenchmarkBase.cs - Benchmark base class
• tests/Umbraco.Tests.Integration/Umbraco.Infrastructure/Services/ContentServiceRefactoringTests.cs - 15 integration tests (Tasks 1-6)
• docs/plans/2025-12-20-contentservice-refactor-phase0-implementation.md - Full implementation plan with code

Action Items & Next Steps

Resume using subagent-driven development workflow starting with Task 7:

1. Task 7: Create ContentServiceRefactoringBenchmarks.cs (NEXT)

   • Large file with 33 benchmarks (~1100 lines)
   • Plan lines 1231-2386 contain the full file content
   • Dispatch implementer subagent with Task 7 context
   • After implementation, dispatch spec reviewer, then code quality reviewer
   • This file creates a NEW file, not modifying existing

2. Task 8: Create ContentServiceBaseTests.cs

   • Unit tests (skeleton with tracking test)
   • Plan lines 2389-2657

3. Tasks 9-11: Verification and baseline capture

   • Run all tests, capture benchmarks, create git tag

Other Notes

• The implementation plan has gone through 3 critical reviews (v1.1, v1.2, v1.3) - all feedback has been incorporated
• Key revision notes are at the top of the plan document
• Benchmark data sizes are standardized to 10/100/1000 pattern (v1.2)
• Warmup logic was corrected for both destructive and non-destructive benchmarks
• ContentServiceBase doesn't exist yet - Task 8 creates tracking test that fails when it's created in Phase 1
• All 15 tests currently in ContentServiceRefactoringTests.cs are passing