Files

yv01p ec1fe5ccea docs: add Phase 4 implementation plan, critical reviews, and summary

- Implementation plan for ContentMoveOperationService extraction
- Two critical review documents with identified issues
- Completion summary confirming all tasks executed

🤖 Generated with [Claude Code](https://claude.com/claude-code)

Co-Authored-By: Claude <noreply@anthropic.com>

2025-12-23 18:16:26 +00:00

3.6 KiB

Raw Blame History

ContentService Refactoring Phase 4: Move Operation Service Implementation Plan - Completion Summary

1. Overview

The original plan specified extracting Move, Copy, Sort, and Recycle Bin operations from ContentService into a dedicated IContentMoveOperationService. The scope included creating an interface in Umbraco.Core, an implementation inheriting from ContentServiceBase, DI registration, ContentService delegation updates, unit tests, integration tests, test verification, design document updates, and git tagging.

Overall Completion Status: FULLY COMPLETE

All 9 tasks from the implementation plan have been successfully executed with all tests passing.

2. Completed Items

Task 1: Created IContentMoveOperationService.cs interface with 10 methods covering Move, Copy, Sort, and Recycle Bin operations
Task 2: Created ContentMoveOperationService.cs implementation (~450 lines) inheriting from ContentServiceBase
Task 3: Registered service in DI container via UmbracoBuilder.cs
Task 4: Updated ContentService.cs to delegate Move/Copy/Sort operations to the new service
Task 5: Created unit tests (ContentMoveOperationServiceInterfaceTests.cs) verifying interface contract
Task 6: Created integration tests (ContentMoveOperationServiceTests.cs) with 19 tests covering all operations
Task 7: Ran full ContentService test suite - 220 passed, 2 skipped
Task 8: Updated design document marking Phase 4 as complete (revision 1.8)
Task 9: Created git tag phase-4-move-extraction

3. Partially Completed or Modified Items

None. All tasks were completed as specified.

4. Omitted or Deferred Items

None. All planned tasks were executed.

5. Discrepancy Explanations

No discrepancies exist between the plan and execution. The implementation incorporated all v1.1 critical review fixes as specified in the plan:

GetPermissions nested scope issue - inlined repository call
navigationUpdates unused variable - removed entirely
GetById(int) method signature - changed to GetByIds pattern
parentKey for descendants in Copy - documented for backwards compatibility
DeleteLocked empty batch handling - break immediately when empty
Page size constants - extracted to class-level constants
Performance logging - added to Sort operation

6. Key Achievements

Full Test Coverage: All 220 ContentService integration tests pass with no regressions
Comprehensive New Tests: 19 new integration tests specifically for ContentMoveOperationService
Critical Review Incorporation: All 8 issues from the critical review were addressed in the implementation
Architectural Consistency: Implementation follows established patterns from Phases 1-3
Proper Orchestration Boundary: MoveToRecycleBin correctly remains in ContentService facade for unpublish orchestration
Git Milestone: Phase 4 tag created for versioning (phase-4-move-extraction)

7. Final Assessment

The Phase 4 implementation fully meets the original plan's intent. The IContentMoveOperationService and ContentMoveOperationService were created with all specified methods (Move, Copy, Sort, EmptyRecycleBin, RecycleBinSmells, GetPagedContentInRecycleBin, EmptyRecycleBinAsync). ContentService now properly delegates to the new service while retaining MoveToRecycleBin for unpublish orchestration. All critical review fixes were incorporated. The test suite confirms behavioral equivalence with the original implementation. The design document and git repository are updated to reflect Phase 4 completion. The refactoring is now positioned to proceed to Phase 5 (Publish Operation Service).

3.6 KiB Raw Blame History